Updated 17 September 2026
A gel eye pencil is usually the easiest option for soft lines and gradual build-up. A felt-tip pen gives controlled, clearly defined lines. A liquid liner with a flexible brush offers the most freedom for thin or broad strokes, but needs a steadier hand. Choose by applicator, verified finish and experience—not by a universal “best” claim.
Quick comparison: which eyeliner format fits?
| Format | Best for | Control | Finish |
|---|---|---|---|
| Twist-up gel eye pencil | soft lines and gradual build-up | high | metallic copper |
| Felt-tip eyeliner pen | precise black lines and wings | high | intense black |
| Liquid brush eyeliner | thin to broad black lines | medium | matte black |
Choose by the problem you want to solve
- If your line tends to wobble: Work in short strokes. A twist-up pencil or felt-tip pen offers more guidance than a flexible brush.
- If you want a soft, shimmering look: The Rosy Copper gel pencil gives a metallic copper line rather than a matte black result.
- If you want very thin or deliberately broader lines: The dip brush is flexible. Shake it before use and wipe excess product on the neck of the bottle.
- If waterproof wear matters: The exact pencil and felt-tip versions are labelled waterproof. That is not a guarantee for every eye, climate or wear time.
Twist-up gel pencil: soft, metallic definition
Catrice 20H Ultra Precision Waterproof eyeliner pencil 110 Rosy Copper, 0.08 g (Catrice Eyeliner 20H Ultra Precision Waterproof 110 Rosy Copper, 0,08 g)
Cosmetic · GTIN 4059729444370 · 0.08 g. The 2 mm twist-up tip applies the soft, waterproof gel texture along the lash line. Rosy Copper is metallic, not black. The manufacturer states wear of up to 20 hours for this exact version; individual results can vary.
View the Rosy Copper gel pencil
Felt-tip pen: controlled black definition
essence Waterproof eyeliner felt-tip pen 01, 1 ml (essence Eyeliner Waterproof 01, 1 ml)
Cosmetic · GTIN 4250587772173 · 1 ml. The fine felt tip is designed for precise, deep-black lines. This exact version is described as waterproof and smudge-resistant. Store it cool and dry and replace the cap after use.
View the waterproof felt-tip pen
Liquid brush liner: flexible thin-to-broad strokes
trend !t up Dip it! liquid brush eyeliner 020 Black, 2.5 ml (trend !t up Eyeliner Dip it! - Brush 020 Black, 2,5 ml)
Cosmetic · GTIN 4067796002454 · 2.5 ml. The soft flexible brush can draw thin or broader lines. Shake well before use. This exact version is described as smudge-resistant; this article does not transfer a waterproof claim to it.
Apply in four calm steps
- Start on a clean, dry eyelid and rest your elbow on a stable surface.
- Place the tip close to the upper lash line and use short strokes instead of one long movement.
- Build thickness and the wing gradually. Shake the liquid brush before use.
- Allow liquid textures to dry briefly and remove eye make-up gently in the evening without rubbing.
Eye-area safety
Use each product only as directed on the eyelid or lash line. This comparison does not establish general suitability for the inner waterline. Do not share eye make-up. Stop using a product if its smell, texture or colour changes noticeably or if irritation occurs.
Frequently asked questions
Is an eye pencil better for beginners?
Often yes, because short strokes and soft edges are easier to control. A felt-tip pen can also suit beginners who want a crisp line.
What is the difference between a felt tip and a brush?
A felt tip keeps its shape and offers more guidance. A flexible brush reacts more to pressure and angle, allowing both thin and broader lines.
Are all three eyeliners black?
No. The Catrice pencil is metallic Rosy Copper. Only the essence pen and trend !t up dip-brush liner are black.
Can I use them on the waterline?
Do not assume so. This comparison covers eyelid and lash-line use because those are the verified directions for the featured products.
✓ VivaVoss dispatches from Germany. Product availability, carrier, delivery time and possible charges depend on the destination and checkout.
Sources and review method
Product class, GTIN, size, INCI, directions, storage and current availability were checked on 17 September 2026 against the exact VivaVoss records and the linked official manufacturer or dm pages. This is a format comparison, not a bestseller or effectiveness ranking.
Editorial transparency: This article and featured visual were prepared with AI assistance. Product information, sources and claims were fact-checked by VivaVoss. VivaVoss retains editorial responsibility.
